All PodcastsEpisode 2

Fighting Fear with Facts: Navigating Infectious Disease Misinformation

Release Date

October 13, 2026

Host

Megan Hall

(Scientific American Custom Media)

Featured Guest

Jessica Malaty Rivera, MS, Epidemiologist & Science Communicator

Focus Areas

How diseases spread, information overload during outbreaks, how online platforms shape what people see, checking whether research results hold up, public health

Summary

Disease outbreaks are often accompanied by a flood of confusing, conflicting, or false information. Epidemiologist Jessica Malaty Rivera joins host Megan Hall to explain how fear-based stories spread, why online platforms often favor dramatic claims over careful explanations, and how public health experts can help people find clear, reliable information.

In this podcast:

  • Two Outbreaks at Once: Understand why disease outbreaks are often accompanied by an overload of information, including rumors and deliberately false claims.
  • Checking That Research Holds Up: Learn how other experts review studies and repeat experiments to check whether the findings are dependable.
  • Pause Before You Share: See how posts designed to trigger fear, anger, or sudden relief can push people toward quick reactions instead of reliable facts.

Transcript

Fighting Fear with Facts: Navigating Infectious Disease Misinformation

Jessica Malaty Rivera: Change makes people feel uncomfortable. It’s a very vulnerable place to be in, especially if people are looked looking at experts as infallible, which they’re very much not.

Megan Hall: Has sensationalism about infectious diseases altered our ability to discern fact from fiction? It’s easy to find bold claims on social media about everything from vaccines to the spread of measles. But how do we know what to trust? I’m Megan Hall for Scientific American Custom Media. How do we respond to real epidemics when we’re also fighting the spread of misinformation? Where can people turn for trusted information, especially to protect themselves from infectious diseases? Joining me is Jessica Malaty Rivera, an epidemiologist and award-winning science communicator. Welcome, Jessica.

Jessica Malaty Rivera: Thanks for having me.

Megan Hall: It’s great to have you. So before we talk about infectious diseases and misinformation, let’s talk a little bit about you. You’ve been translating science information for a long time, but I understand you were an actual translator starting at the age of one. Is that correct?

Jessica Malaty Rivera: Yeah, it’s true. The joke is that my parents didn’t really know how proficient I was in English, until I was translating a private conversation to a nosy neighbor from Arabic to English, and they were like, “Oh, my gosh, it’s not a safe place anymore.” So I guess it was in my genes.

Megan Hall: And then you went on to do other translating as well. Is that true?

Jessica Malaty Rivera: Yes. I got my introduction to science communication as a literal translator. I was working on a very cool project at Georgetown University in the early 2000s that was tasked with using open-source media to identify early indicators and warnings of emerging biological threats. And that was using public media in different languages. I was translating the media from Arabic and Spanish, those are the languages that I was using at the time, into English, but then also translating the science in those articles into accessible language for a mostly lay audience. And I realized that that was where my brain really lit up, that the sense making of it all was more exciting to me than even the science itself.

Megan Hall: Talk a little bit about that, because you said you weren’t formally trained in science communication, but you sort of picked it up at Georgetown. So what were some of the informal things you picked up?

Jessica Malaty Rivera: So, there is a language of science, and you are taught it in school, and you were taught to repeat it in school. And translating it is a different type of skill. We were very much tasked in this job to make it make sense to people who didn’t have the training that we had. And I loved doing that. It was a challenge at first. It was: How do I simplify this without diluting the message? How do I explain it without misappropriating risk and the context that was necessary to understand it all. And it was very consequential information because we were trying to understand: Could this be an emerging epidemic? Could this be something that could be catastrophic to a community? And our team actually found some of the earliest signs of the 2009 H1N1 pandemic. And we were piecing together clues like shortage of ventilators and pigs getting culled and the farmers of the pig farms getting sick. And those are all really interesting clues that we then translated and turned into a summary to help people understand what was going on in the field. And as I was doing it for several years, I just got better and better at it, and I just fell in love.

Megan Hall: So, you were doing this sort of science translating for a long time, but you went online. You were doing the social-media stuff during Covid. And I understand it started just because friends were asking you questions?

Jessica Malaty Rivera: I was fielding a lot of text messages and phone calls and emails from friends who were like, weren’t you talking about pandemics 20 years ago at Georgetown? And I was like, yeah, I really was. And that was because we always knew it was a matter of when, not if. And so, at the time, I had a private Instagram account and I thought, well, if these are such frequently asked questions, I can turn it into, like, perhaps a series to also just not be on my phone texting all the time and just answer them, you know, one at a time and share it and say, it’s on my Instagram.

Megan Hall: Not every time, not every text.

Jessica Malaty Rivera: Yes, not every text. I had young kids at the time. I just didn’t want to be on my phone at all times, and I mean, I actually walked into being on my phone way more by opening up my social media to the public. But I’m so glad I did because, I think it, I know it revealed an incredibly curious and captivated audience that wanted this content that at the time was not very common on social media, and so I did it to meet a need. And I was hearing from my community, “I don’t know where to look, or there’s too much information. Help me navigate it.” And so I thought, well, I’ll just make it all make sense here in one place.

Megan Hall: I remember how desperate we were back then for good information. I mean, there was so much panic, and I found myself watching Zooms of a doctor I didn’t even know that someone had sent me, but it was a bunch of people listening to their friend and the doctor, just saying, “Help us. What’s going on here?” What was that like for you?

Jessica Malaty Rivera: It was wild because even though my familiarity with infectious diseases, emerging infectious diseases, coronaviruses, viruses that can turn into pandemics, I was also in the same information ecosystems that everybody else was in, trying to understand what was true, what was not true, what was evidence-based, what was sensationalist. And even for trained eyes, we had to really, like, make sure that we were getting trusted sources for this information. I think there’s a little bit of misremembering about Covid-19 and the pandemic, and I was trying my best to bring the human into the story and say, look, this is a fallible system because we’re all fallible people. We’re going to get some things wrong. There’s going to be a lot of uncertainty; there’s going to be some changes. And I was trying to give people a little bit of resilience to what they can expect for the years to come. I couldn’t have predicted it lasted as long as it did, but I was trying to give people at least some expectation that this was going to be complicated and ever evolving.

Megan Hall: What do you say to the people that believe that there is sort of a backlash against science information because they thought that the science expert said, “Trust us. This is how Covid is, this is how it works,” and then they gave new information?

Jessica Malaty Rivera: I mean, how much time do we have? Because this is the thing that honestly still keeps me up at night, because I’ve grown to deeply hate some of those sentences like, trust the science, trust the experts, because they became meaningless. And they were used, honestly, very ineffectively, and harmfully, to silence people, to make people feel shame for asking questions. I was trying to bring honesty and humility into the space and instead there was just a lot of: which team are you on, whose side are you on? And science is iterative. That’s, again, what I was trying to give people kind of that familiarity with. It’s not static. This is emerging. We are all experiencing this in real time. There’s no, “Oh, I already know because I’ve been through this experience of COVID-19,” during the pandemic.” And so because of that, I was trying to say, “Hey, let’s all like let’s walk through this together.” It’s why I led a lot of my sentences with how I was perceiving risk, what I was doing for my children to manage their risk, what I was doing to manage my own. So that I could let people know that I was experiencing it just as acutely as they were or at least to some people who may have had similar experiences.

Megan Hall: So how do we help people expect those moments where the science changes, so they don’t lose trust?

Jessica Malaty Rivera: Yeah, I talk about it. I talk about how science changes, how science should change. Now, there are situations in which it doesn’t change a lot, which is a good thing, but it’s because we have our own internal checks-and-balances system. The reason why we have the scientific method, the reason why we have peer review, is our own way of keeping ourselves accountable. I mean, I talk a lot about even the methods of a study and how reproducibility is such an amazing standard, but it sounds like a wonky word, and I’m basically saying, look, if I’m saying A plus B equals C in California, and I give you my methods in Rhode Island, you can say, you know what, I did it, and I got the same results. That’s a great way to check your math, to check your work. And so, I tell people, we are trying our best to constantly check, to constantly audit ourselves. Sometimes it gets a little bit better, and you can see that reflected in recommendations changing or guidance changing, and change makes people feel uncomfortable. It’s a very vulnerable place to be in, especially if people are looking at experts as infallible, which they’re very much not. So, I’m trying to remind people. Remember, it’s humans. Data does not exist in the natural world. All data are created, and I talk about that.

Megan Hall: So, what can scientists do to be worthy of trust? What should they be doing?

Jessica Malaty Rivera: Yeah, I think being deeply honest about errors is incredible, is very important. Saying we don’t know, or we don’t know yet. I’ve seen scientists squirm, but isn’t that the whole process of science? Aren’t we all in science because of curiosity and wanting to answer questions for which we don’t have the answers? I think being more comfortable with uncertainty and discussing uncertainty builds trust and trustworthiness. I think that talking about revisions that needed to happen in a way that does not have binary framing builds trust. I think talking about things in ways that are personal and using storytelling is another way to build trust. I mean, I know that the plural of anecdote is not data, but anecdotes are incredibly powerful for compelling people to make decisions. And that’s why I do a lot of my science communication as personalized as possible with a grounding in evidence.

Megan Hall: So, how do you balance admitting that you don’t know something, giving nuanced answers, with the way social media works, which is: it rewards binary, it rewards fear, it rewards certainty, and monologues and screeds?

Jessica Malaty Rivera: This is the challenge of my life right now, because I feel like the algorithm also is this very nebulous thing I’m trying to understand, and it’s also evolving. And unfortunately, the algorithms are rewarding sensationalist, binary hot takes, armchair epidemiology, and expertise in general. I think the combination of both, like a death of expertise and the rise in armchair expertise, has made it very difficult to understand what is real, because anybody with a really nice microphone and a nice-looking face and a good setup and good lighting can seem like an expert. There’s psychology literature about this too; it’s called the halo effect, where somebody who might have expertise in a topic is very eloquent and poised. People will assign expertise on topics outside of their actual expertise, because they’re like, well, they’re probably really smart, and they can talk about a lot of things. Or they assume that because they seem nice, that they mean well in all things. And I think that is a terribly troubling consequence of the rise of social media and video-based content, and also the deprioritization of content moderation. There used to be a better checks-and-balances system in these algorithms to help reduce the risk of that. And now it is very difficult to play that game.

Megan Hall: So, for people navigating conflicting health information online, how can they evaluate whether a source is credible, and distinguish legitimate health risks from misinformation designed to provoke fear, outrage or confusion?

Jessica Malaty Rivera: So, one of the first things I tell people to do is to check in with themselves, to ask themselves, how does this make me feel? Is this making me feel like I have been betrayed, I’ve been lied to? Is there hidden information that I don’t have access to? Do I feel angry? Does it make me hate a group more, or love a group more? Does it confirm a bias that I have or confirm an affiliation that I have with a certain group, and to have a moment to check in with those feelings, because a lot of times content is created to specifically target or trigger those emotions.

Megan Hall: Today, there’s the threat of both epidemics and infodemics. Tell me about the challenges of each one.

Jessica Malaty Rivera: So, we live in a world in which emerging epidemics are a threat, because we live with multiple ecosystems—humans, plants, animals—that exist with each other. And there are new viruses, and humans spread viruses to each other. And epidemics are an expected outcome of living in the natural world. They don’t always have to be terrible pandemics, but epidemics happen. That’s an outbreak of a pathogen. Infodemics are both a driver of them and a consequence of them. You can define an infodemic as an outbreak of either too much information, or too much information that includes harmful information, mis- and disinformation. And those two kind of exist in this really terrible cycle and have existed in a terrible cycle as tandem outbreaks for a very long time. But an infodemic is unique because it’s sometimes just too much information, and it makes it difficult, even for the most discerning eyes, to know about that. But for as long as we’ve had epidemics, there have been terrible takes about that epidemic, which contributes to infodemics. We can go way way way back. We can talk about smallpox and how the smallpox vaccine was derived, and when it was, and they used cowpox to create that vaccine. There were propaganda posts in newspapers and sermons preached from pulpits that people would turn into cows if they took the vaccine. That is in the history books. You can describe that as an infodemic. You can describe that as an outbreak of harmful information, wild information, incorrect information that exacerbates the consequences of an epidemic.

Megan Hall: So, what is it about us, you know, this is kind of in us even before social media, that we’re susceptible to these wild claims?

Jessica Malaty Rivera: It’s a deeply human effect. Humans want to make sense of a world that constantly confuses them and disappoints them and harms them. And it is very human to want to connect dots. That’s why the word heuristic is used to describe some of these things, these mental shortcuts that we make to make sense of the world. That’s why we have all these fallacies that we are susceptible to, like correlation and causation. I noticed a dramatic increase in engagement when I started doing front-facing video, which was mortifying to me because as an elder millennial, I didn’t want to do that. I didn’t want to take a selfie. I remember I told my husband, don’t even look at me when I’m doing this, because it was so deeply embarrassing. Now it’s so normal. But I realized people wanted to see my face and to hear my voice and to see that I was a mom, and there may have been toys in the background, or a kitchen that looked like it was a little bit messy. That normalized and humanized me as a communicator. I think that goes a long way. It sounds so simple, but it really was bringing the human to the conversation, because my beautiful graphs and charts and beautifully designed Canva posts just didn’t do it for everybody.

Megan Hall: Is there a time when you accidentally fell for something?

Jessica Malaty Rivera: Absolutely. A lot of it was related to, I’m a mom. I have three young kids, and as a mom, I wanted the best for my children. And even though I would consider myself a pretty science-literate, informed person, I was really worried about a lot of things for them as kids and thought that certain types of foods would be better or certain types of things could be solutions for their pain. I remember somebody suggested I get amber beads for my child when they were teething.

Megan Hall: I remember that.

Jessica Malaty Rivera: I bought one, and I’m like, there is no data that is compelling enough to justify this. Plus, it’s a choking hazard. And I actually used my money and bought an amber necklet for my child. And again, it was not like a crazy conspiracy, but I wanted the best for my child. I read information that seemed like it was going to help my child, and I made a decision because of that. I think that talking about that also helps bring the human into the conversation, because I really do not think anybody is immune to making a choice that is based on a claim that is not verified.

Megan Hall: Let’s go back to some basics. We’ve talked about evidence-based, but I want to just make sure we define terms. So, will you explain what evidence-based science means?

Jessica Malaty Rivera: That’s another phrase that I am kind of leaning away from too, because it has been used as a way to signal virtue of something being good or right. It is an absolutely true attribute of something that is rigorously tested, has evidence to be based on. Right? And that is what people should be looking towards, not claims that don’t have evidence. And what we mean by evidence is data. Has there been a trial to verify this that has some controls in it that can do that checks and balances internally? Has it been assessed for a period of time that is meaningful? Is it based on anecdotes or is it based on, you know, actual experiments? Those are ways in which we can justify something being called evidence-based. But sometimes it’s just a label, like a marketing label. And that can get really convoluted too. See, you see backed by science or science-based for a lot of wellness products that are not actually based in science, but they look sciency. So, you have to be careful with all the terms. I think at this point.

Megan Hall: So, should we stop using evidence-based? Is it a term that has lost its meaning?

Jessica Malaty Rivera: No. I just think we should be defining it whenever we use it. So, I would say if I’m going to claim that something is evidence-based, I’m going to tell you what the evidence is that it’s based on.

Megan Hall: It’s sort of like when you go grocery shopping and something just says natural.

Jessica Malaty Rivera: A hundred percent. A meaningless term. Lots of things are natural. Lots of terrible things are natural. Nature is trying to kill us in many ways, right? Whether it’s like natural disasters or diseases and pathogens that are emerging. Nature is not safe in that sense, right? And so, this appeal-to-nature fallacy is another one of those fallacies where you think natural is better. But nature has been killing humans since the beginning of time.

Megan Hall: So, with the rise of AI, people are getting health information from chatbots and large language models more and more. Are these sources people can trust?

Jessica Malaty Rivera: That is such a tough question to answer, because it’s not a monolith. There’s a difference between generative AI and AI, and it’s a very complicated topic, because I have seen it both used for good and used for terrible.

Megan Hall: How would you advise people to evaluate information coming out of AI?

Jessica Malaty Rivera: I would never tell people to put personal health information into AI and ask for interpretation or diagnostics. I would absolutely not recommend that. I would also tell people to take it with a grain of salt, that you would have to look at this as something that would always need to be verified, especially if you were asking for things like citations. We saw this happen even from officials, where hallucinated citations that look sciency were mentioned or cited in a report. And I do think that that is a very real concern about what that could do for the future of care. I mean, God forbid you see a clinical trial that was hallucinated be a citation for a treatment or a decision a physician would make. That is a worst-case scenario. And so, I would tell people to tread very lightly, to not use that as infallible truth, to always complement that with talking to your provider.

Megan Hall: So, a central idea of Bayer’s Science Delivers campaign is that real science comes from a rigorous process of gathering and interrogating evidence. Why is that process important?

Jessica Malaty Rivera: It’s so important because we want to provide the most effective, the most safe, the most trusted answers to people. And when people either consider it as something that is haphazard or not done with as much care and rigor and thoughtfulness, it’s both an insult, but it also just cheapens the process, because it allows people to do the shortcuts that I feel like science is often accused of taking, and we’re not. It’s long, it’s arduous. Anybody who’s been a clinical researcher knows, you could spend your whole career trying to answer one question. You can spend decades trying to see one intervention go from a phase-1 trial to an actual marketed product. So, it’s a long, labor, marathon type of work. And I think that inviting people into that process, and showing them the type of blood, sweat and tears that it takes to create science—it’s not just done willy nilly in some room—is important in helping people understand and to be confident in the process.

Megan Hall: So, how are you hoping that online conversations about health and science improve?

Jessica Malaty Rivera: I’m hoping that there is more humanity in it all. There’s a lot of rage, understandable rage. There’s a lot of emotions, understandable emotions. And I want to bring people into the human process of it all. I want to humanize scientists. I want to humanize the experience of doing the work of science, because as we’re seeing it being attacked and defunded and maligned by so many different groups, I think that understanding that science is everywhere, that public health is everywhere, that oftentimes it is invisible, but the reason why we’re able to do so many things, including creating content on the internet, I hope that that can help make so much of the invisible things that we take for granted more visible.

Megan Hall: Jessica Malaty Rivera, it has been such a pleasure talking to you. Thank you for joining me.

Jessica Malaty Rivera: You as well. Thank you for having me.

Megan Hall: This podcast was produced by Scientific American Custom Media and made possible through the support of Bayer.