All PodcastsEpisode 3
Finding Nutrition Truth in a World of Myths
Release Date
Host
Megan Hall
(Scientific American Custom Media)
Featured Guest
Focus Areas
Summary
In an online world filled with quick fixes and restrictive diet trends, nutrition scientist Dr. Jessica Knurick explains how to judge food claims by looking at the full body of research. Speaking with Megan Hall, Dr. Knurick explains why one person’s experience cannot replace findings from many studies and why overall eating habits matter far more than cutting out a single ingredient.
In this podcast:
- Looking at the Full Picture: Discover why conclusions drawn from many high-quality studies are usually more reliable than a single study or one person’s experience.
- When Two Things Happen Together: Learn why two trends happening at the same time does not necessarily mean that one caused the other—and how overlooking other factors can lead to misleading health claims.
- Building Healthy Habits: Focus on consistent habits—such as eating enough fiber, choosing a range of whole foods, and getting varied nutrients—instead of following extreme diets that remove entire food groups.
Transcript
Finding Nutrition Truth in a World of Myths
Jessica Knurick: I see videos all the time that will start with something like, are you poisoning your kids? Because that’s like a hook, and you’re like, I don’t want to poison my kids. I need to keep watching. And I always try to tell people: evidence-based practitioners like scientists, medical professionals, the ones operating in a really evidence-based way, are never going to do that.
Megan Hall: Do Americans have a credible source for information about nutrition and food? The internet is full of so-called experts with lots of advice about what you should be eating. But can you trust them? I’m Megan Hall for Scientific American Custom Media. Everywhere you look, there’s a new food trend or a supplement that promises to transform your health. Where do we find reliable information among the noise? Joining me is Dr. Jessica Knurick, a nutrition scientist, registered dietitian and science communicator. Welcome, Jessica.
Jessica Knurick: Thank you so much. It’s so good to be here with you.
Megan Hall: So, before we talk about misinformation and nutrition, let’s talk about your backstory. I understand you started thinking about food and nutrition because of your grandfather?
Jessica Knurick: Yeah, I grew up living very close, about a mile down the road from my grandpa. He was young. He was in his mid 40s when I was born. And when I was in high school, he was diagnosed with type two diabetes. And so, we had kind of understood from what the doctor said that he should decrease his sugar intake, that he should stop eating so much sugar. So, we really took that to heart. At the time, it was very much a lot of sugar-free options in the grocery store. Any time we’d be at a grocery store, we’d look for a sugar-free option. He liked candy. He loved sweets. He loved, like, donuts and ice cream. And we would just get him a sugar-free version of that, thinking that that’s what we were supposed to be doing, because that was what we had heard. And it obviously was not the right approach, but he got a lot of joy out of it. And then a couple of years later, we lived in Michigan and so it was January and he was snow blowing the snow off of his driveway, and he had a heart attack, and he passed away. And he was only in his 60s. And so that really made me start to think more about, you know, why did that happen? What more could we have done for him and really start thinking about nutrition and exercise and just prevention of things like cardiometabolic disease.
Megan Hall: So that sort of puts you on your mission to be looking into these topics?
Jessica Knurick: Yeah, when I decided to go to grad school, we had to figure out what we were going to do, and it really made me start to think about wanting to understand more about type two diabetes and just cardiometabolic disease in general, like cardiovascular disease, and how we could really look at the preventive side of that. So, it’s definitely why I went into the field that I did, which was the prevention of these chronic diseases.
Megan Hall: So, you know, people like your grandfather who get diagnosed with diabetes or they are told they need to watch what they’re eating, it’s easy for them to get misinformation or get attached to fads that don’t have anything to do with the science. So, let’s talk about that. Let’s talk about the state of our information about food. What’s the biggest challenge getting reliable information about nutrition for everyday people like your grandfather?
Jessica Knurick: Yeah, I think one of the interesting things about nutrition is that it’s very much a science, but it’s also something that’s deeply personal for people because we all eat, right? Multiple times a day. We’re all constantly thinking about food. Very differently than other areas of science where it doesn’t feel so intimate and personal. And so, I think because of that, you know, we all have a lot of opinions about nutrition and food, and we all have experiences where we ate a certain way and it helped us feel better. And, you know, with the information ecosystem we have now, people will then take to that—whether it’s social media or wherever it is—and, kind of use those anecdotes, and it really muddies the waters when you think of the hierarchy of scientific evidence, because in that kind of information ecosystem, a personal anecdote can appear the same as, say, a meta-analysis or scientific consensus in an area. And, so, I think it becomes this really difficult thing to weed through what is true versus what is not, because one person is going to have an anecdote where they stopped eating a certain food and felt better, and then the other person started eating that food and felt better. So, you’ll hear two conflicting things, and it seems like nobody really understands what they’re talking about. But, at the end of the day, that’s because of more about how the information’s being presented than what the actual science says.
Megan Hall: For people who don’t know, what is a meta-analysis, and why is that a useful tool for understanding nutrition advice or other science information?
Megan Hall: So, what’s your reaction when an expert online cites one study as proof that people need to eat a certain way?
Megan Hall: Related to that, a recent Harris Study Poll commissioned by Bayer found that 1 in 5 young adults distrust doctors and scientists as sources of information. So, why do you think that’s the case? Is that related to just being in the wrong spaces, not talking to people where they are?
Jessica Knurick: I think there’s probably a few reasons. I think a lot of people, because of the way our medical system is in this country, feel really disillusioned with the medical system. So, they may have had a bad experience, and they feel like they’re not getting enough from our current medical system. And so, they go elsewhere for information. I think a lot of people feel that way. I think they blame the doctors when perhaps more of the blame should go on the system itself and the fact that doctors are operating in this ecosystem or in this environment where they have 15 minutes with you. They don’t have a lot of follow-up time. We’re not integrating preventive care well into the healthcare system. And so, people are like, well, I need to go figure this out on my own. And so, I think that’s a big thing that can breed distrust. I also think it’s part of what I was saying, in terms of scientists: many people have never met a scientist or they didn’t know that they did. It’s kind of like, oh, what are these scientists doing. When you don’t know someone, when you don’t know the person or you don’t know this profession, it’s very easy to kind of paint them as the boogie-man, right? So, I think part of communication and effective science communication is just more people being more accessible to people and putting your face out there, and then people are more willing to listen to how science is not necessarily this boogie-man and just explaining the process, so you can start to build more trust.
Megan Hall: In our interview with Dr. Noc, he was saying that the first time he really broke through to his audience was when he was on a call, and he said, “I have to leave, my wife’s coming home and I need to make dinner,” and that there was something about him humanizing himself that made people trust him. So, do you think that’s part of it just being a normal human being that helps people trust scientists and doctors more?
Jessica Knurick: Yeah, I think absolutely. I think it’s like a relatability aspect. If they can see themselves in you, they’re more willing to listen to you and trust you. You know, if they can see that, oh, I’m a mom with two little kids, and I care about my kids’ health, and I care about what they’re consuming, and I care about, you know, putting them in the best position in life to grow and have a healthy life. Then they can trust me more, right? Because they know, oh, I care about my kids too. And they can see themselves in me. If I have little kids, I’m caring about my kids, then they’re like, “Oh, she has kids, too. She cares. Why would she want to poison her kids?” You know what I mean?
Megan Hall: So, if she’s giving me advice, she is also doing this with her own family. She’s not lecturing me. This is what she’s decided to do too.
Jessica Knurick: Yeah, and I think there’s an aspect there that’s very important to humanize the person giving the information, for sure. I like to know the person I’m getting information from. I’m more willing to listen to that person, if I know something about them. Oh, you played college basketball. That’s so interesting. You know, just like little relatability factors, I think can help to increase trust.
Megan Hall: Is there a food trend that really bothers you?
Jessica Knurick: Yeah. Lots of them.
Megan Hall: Give me one.
Jessica Knurick: I mean, in our current environment, I think the idea that there are individual ingredients or even individual foods that are going to make or break your health is probably the biggest one for me. I think we focus and fixate a lot on individual things and think, if I just remove this from my diet, I’m going to be healthier. Outside of, if you have an allergy or some sort of medical condition where you need to remove that food, that’s just not the way nutrition works. Nutrition is very much more so about your overall dietary pattern, what you’re consuming day in and day out, and then the individual things overall don’t really make a big difference. And so, I think if we could get more people to kind of understand that aspect of it, where it’s about your dietary pattern, what you’re eating overall, the whole 80/20 rule that you always hear about—but it really is true. Like, what are you eating the bulk of the time? And then you don’t necessarily need to eliminate or remove any individual ingredients or foods.
Megan Hall: So, that means I can eat carbs? Is that what you’re telling me?
Jessica Knurick: You can eat one out of the three macronutrients. Yes, you can eat carbs. You can also eat fat and protein.
Megan Hall: What about the obsession with protein? I feel like I’m seeing that online so much that I’m just supposed to eat as much protein as possible.
Jessica Knurick: Yeah, I think it comes from villainizing carbs and fat because there’s only three macronutrients. There’s only three places you can get your calories, right? And so a lot of people view carbs as problematic. A lot of people view fat as problematic, and so they’re like, oh, protein. I need protein in everything that I eat. So at the end of the day, that’s not true. Like you need a balance of all three, and a balance of all three is very healthful and health promoting.
Megan Hall: So, we can appreciate food trends, but put this in perspective for me: how can these misinformed posts be dangerous for our health?
Jessica Knurick: Yeah, I mean, I can tell you what I experience in my DMs every day are people who are very scared about our food environment. They have a ton of anxiety about what they’re eating, what they’re feeding their kids. If you think about social media and the reward structure of social media, the most sensational—the more sensational the claim, the more fear-based the claim—the better that video often does. And so, if you’re like, I see videos all the time, that will start with something like, are you poisoning your kids? Because that’s like a hook and you’re like, I don’t want to poison my kids. I need to keep watching. And I always try to tell people, evidence-based practitioners like scientists, medical professionals, the ones operating in a really evidence-based way are never going to do that. They’re just not going to open with a hook like that and scare you. But those are the videos people are seeing all the time in their algorithm. And so, you know, they get very scared of these individual foods, or they get scared to eat something because it has a certain ingredient. And so, I think it’s really important to just kind of understand where you’re getting your information from, because it’s causing a lot of anxiety. So, that’s one of the things, I think. You know, I’d have to look at the data on this to see how it’s impacting eating disorders, but certainly I’m seeing just anecdotally a lot of people in my comment section with a lot of fear and anxiety around food.
Megan Hall: So, you’ve alluded to this, but just directly name some red flags that people should look out for when they’re getting nutrition advice online.
Jessica Knurick: I think number one is those inflammatory kinds of statements, right?
Megan Hall: Ice cream is causing shark bites?
Jessica Knurick: Now, if we conflated correlation and causation, imagine designing a policy where you prohibit ice cream sales in order to prevent shark attacks. Would that work? No, because those things are just correlated and they’re confounded by weather, right? So, as it gets warmer, ice cream or ice cream sales and shark attacks both increase. But one of those things doesn’t cause the other, right? So, correlations are very important because those are observations. We see two things increasing over time or in a given period together. But then you need to go design a study to actually assess for causation. And so, a lot of people will just kind of put two graphs up. Let’s say it’s like over 40 years and two things have increased. And then they’ll just imply on their video that one of those things is causing the other with absolutely no evidence that that’s the case. And if you are already predisposed to want that to be the case, it’s very easy to say, “Oh yeah, that’s definitely accurate.” So, I think, watching out for that and just kind of knowing that that’s the case. And then, I think the last one is a lot of times with science communication with people on social media, they will use mechanisms to then extrapolate that to make it seem like that’s something, especially in nutrition this happens. So, we have like mechanistic studies that maybe were seen in a in a petri dish in the lab or in an animal model, and some there’s some sort of mechanism that’s happened, and then they extrapolate that to say that that happens in a human and that that impacts a health outcome. But we have no data on that, and there’s a lot of mechanisms that we think are going to work in a human, and human bodies are very complex, and then it it doesn’t work at all, and so taking kind of those mechanistic studies and then say like insinuating that it is true in a human without any human data, I think is really problematic as well. So look out for that.
Megan Hall: What advice do you give to anyone who’s trying to navigate online nutrition information?
Jessica Knurick: Yeah, I think number one, look out for those red flags. Know that the vast majority of information out there is misleading. There’s data on this. The vast majority of nutrition information on social media is not accurate or misleading. And so just, kind of, go into it with that understanding and knowledge. I think it’s important also to look at the source. Look at who you’re getting your information from. This is not foolproof. Certainly, it’s not necessarily that like: if somebody is this kind of expert, they’re going to give good information. But it’s a good starting point. So, is the person who’s giving you information in this area trained in this area? Do they have an education in this area. Are they talking about it from a place of experience where they’ve worked in this area? And then from there, look for those red flags, right? So, are they are they citing their sources? Are they adding nuance? Are they providing you with additional information, or are they just kind of giving inflammatory claims? Oh, one of the red flags I didn’t mention is selling something on the back end, right? So, are they giving you a fear-based statement or some sort of scary claim, and then on the back end selling you a solution to a problem they made up? That happens all the time, right? So, look out for those types of things, and and those can be some red flags and some filters for you if the information is accurate. Is anything?
Megan Hall: Has anything interesting come out in the past few years that you’re excited about?
Jessica Knurick: I think what I’m excited about is just consistently adding to the body of research we do have, particularly around like: what are the most health promoting when it comes to lifestyle-related chronic disease? Like cardiometabolic disease, type two diabetes? What are the dietary eating patterns that are most health-promoting for people? We have research that continuously adds to this body of research evidence to show what those dietary eating patterns look like. And they’re very much based on eating a lot of fruits and vegetables, eating nuts and seeds, and a variety of protein from plant and animal sources and limiting things like added sugar, too much sodium and saturated fat. And so, I get excited every time we have a huge trial that kind of adds to that body of literature. And then I also think ultra-processed foods are being discussed quite a bit right now. And, you know, Kevin Hall did a lot of good work at the NIH on this particular topic, kind of looking at, well, what are the mechanisms of action like. First of all, do ultra-processed foods lead to overeating? And when one of his studies showed that it does, so if you’re eating a diet that’s predominantly ultra-processed foods, which our food environment is predominantly these ultra-processed foods, does that lead to over eating? And then what are the mechanisms driving that? And so, you know, right now what the hypothesis is—and what we would say is—it’s most likely stripping out the fiber, and stripping out, kind of, the bulk of the food and then adding salt, sugar, fat, which means that you just want to eat more of them. I think it’s going to be really interesting to see kind of where that research goes. Right now, we use a classification that’s called the NOVA classification to define ultra-processed foods. It’s not the best classification to regulate these foods because within that definition, there’s a huge variety of nutrition in terms of the foods that you’re getting. So, there can be really nutrient-dense ultra-processed foods, and then really low nutrient, what we think of as ultra processed foods, which are the ones we would recommend limiting.
Megan Hall: What’s your one piece of nutrition advice, if you could only give one?
Jessica Knurick: One piece of nutrition advice? I think focus on your overall dietary pattern. So, make sure that when you’re focused on nutrition, when you’re thinking about nutrition, you’re thinking, what can I improve in my overall dietary pattern? So, what am I eating day in and day out? Not what are the things I need to exclude from my diet. Not what do I need to just restrict for a short amount of time, or go on this super, like, restrictive diet? 95 percent of Americans don’t meet fiber intake guidelines. Over 50 percent of us eat too much added sugar. Over 90 percent of us don’t meet vegetable intake guidelines. And so, a lot of Americans can make huge, meaningful differences by just implementing some of those things. Add more fruits and vegetables to your diet. Make sure you’re conscious of them on a fiber that you’re getting, and look at overall dietary patterns. What has been very consistent in nutrition-science research over many decades is dietary pattern, right? What is your overall dietary pattern look like? Are you basing that in as many nutrient-dense foods as you can, and then the rest doesn’t matter as much.
Megan Hall: Well, Dr. Jessica Knurick, it’s been so great talking to you. Thank you for joining me today.
Jessica Knurick: Thank you so much for having me.
Megan Hall: This video podcast was produced by Scientific American Custom Media and made possible through the support of Bayer.